How to Hire a Remodeling Contractor You Can Trust

To hire a remodeling contractor you can trust in Pennsylvania, work through five steps in order: verify the contractor’s state registration number, confirm their insurance directly with the insurer, collect bids built on one written scope, check references from jobs that are two or three years old, and read the contract against the terms Pennsylvania actually requires before you sign anything.

Most homeowners do some version of steps two through five. The first one takes about ninety seconds, filters out more bad contractors than the other four combined, and almost nobody does it.

Step 1: Look Up the Registration Number

Pennsylvania has no statewide general contractor license. That surprises people, and it’s why the standard advice to “check their license” sends homeowners looking for a document that doesn’t exist.

What Pennsylvania has instead is registration. Under the Home Improvement Consumer Protection Act, passed in 2008, anyone who offers or performs home improvements in the state has to register with the Office of Attorney General.

Subcontractors included. Out of state contractors included. The only exemptions are contractors doing less than $5,000 of home improvement work in a calendar year and retailers worth more than $50 million.

Registration produces a number in a specific format: the letters PA followed by digits, like PA123456. That number has to appear on their advertising, their contracts, their estimates and their proposals. Not on request. On the document.

So the ninety second check is this:

1. Look at the estimate you were handed. If there’s no PA number on it, you already know something.
2. Search the number or the business name in the Attorney General’s Home Improvement Contractor Search at hicsearch.attorneygeneral.gov, which lets you search by registration number, business name, owner name or county.
3. Or call the Bureau of Consumer Protection at 1-888-520-6680 and ask.

Working unregistered is a violation of the act, and unregistered contractors face legal action including civil penalties of $1,000 or more. A contractor who never bothered to register has told you how they treat rules that apply to them.

One caveat matters here: registration is a filter, not an endorsement. The state checks that the paperwork and the insurance exist. It does not check whether the work is any good.

---

Step 2: Understand What “Licensed and Insured” Actually Covers

Every contractor in the state says licensed and insured. Behind that phrase sits a specific, and fairly low, bar.

To register, a contractor has to show proof of general liability coverage of at least $50,000 for personal injury and at least $50,000 for property damage. The Attorney General’s own guidance adds a line worth reading twice: that insurance is not related to contractor performance or quality of work.

So the minimum covers somebody getting hurt or something getting broken. It does not cover the job being done badly, and $50,000 is a floor, not a serious number for a house.

Two things to do about that:

• Ask for a certificate of insurance sent directly from their agent, not a PDF forwarded from the contractor. Certificates are easy to fake and easy to leave expired. The agent will confirm the policy is active and tell you the real coverage limits, which for an established remodeler are usually far above the state minimum.
• Ask specifically about workers compensation for anyone who’ll be on your property. If an uninsured worker gets hurt in your house, the question of who is responsible can land closer to you than you’d like.

---

Step 3: Get Bids You Can Actually Compare

Three bids is the standard advice and it’s fine advice, but it only works if all three are pricing the same job. Hand three contractors a vague description and you’ll get three different projects at three different prices, and you’ll have learned nothing except who is cheapest at guessing.

Write a scope of work before you call anybody: what’s being removed, what’s being installed, what stays, and which decisions are still open. Give every contractor the same document.

Then read the bids for structure, not just the total:

• Is labor separated from materials?
• Are allowances stated in dollars for anything you haven’t picked yet?
• Are permits and inspection fees included or excluded?
• Is there a line for demolition and disposal?
• Does it name specific products, or just “tile” and “fixtures”?

A bid that comes in dramatically under the others is not usually a bargain. It’s usually a different scope, a thinner allowance, or a bid that plans to make its margin back later.

---

Step 4: Check the Right References

Ask for three references, but be specific about which ones: jobs completed two or three years ago, not last month. Fresh work looks great in a photo. Two year old work tells you whether the grout held, whether the trim moved, and whether the contractor came back when something needed attention.

The questions that produce useful answers aren’t about satisfaction. They’re about friction:

• What went wrong on your project, and how did they handle it?
• Did the final price match the contract, and if not, why?
• How were changes handled, and did you get them in writing?
• Did the crew clean up at the end of each day?
• Would you use them again for something bigger?

Every remodel has a bad week. A reference who can describe the bad week and how the contractor showed up during it is worth ten five star reviews.

Also look at the reviews that are two and three stars rather than the ones at the extremes. That’s where the pattern lives.

---

Step 5: Read the Contract Against What Pennsylvania Requires

Any home improvement over $500 in Pennsylvania has to be under a written contract signed by both you and the contractor, and the law names what that contract has to carry.

What the contract must include	What to check before signing
A description of the work	Detailed enough to argue from later, with named products where they’re chosen
Approximate start and completion dates	Real dates, not “spring” or “when we can get to it”
The total price of the contract	One number, with allowances broken out
Notice of your right to cancel	Present in writing, not just mentioned in conversation
The contractor’s registration number	The PA number, matching what you looked up in step one

Two provisions are worth understanding before you sign rather than after.

The cancellation right has teeth. You have three business days to cancel a home improvement contract, and the notice of that right has to be given to you in writing. If it was never given, the entire contract may be voidable even after the three days have passed.

Time and materials work has a cap. If any part of the job is priced by time and materials rather than a fixed number, Pennsylvania requires a written initial cost estimate up front, and the cost can’t exceed 10 percent above that estimate unless you sign a written change order approving the difference.

---

Step 6: Structure the Payments

The deposit is where trust gets tested first. The general rule under Pennsylvania’s act is that a down payment shouldn’t exceed one third of the contract price, or one third plus the cost of materials that have to be special ordered.

A contractor asking for half up front, or for the full amount before starting, is asking you to finance their business. On a job of any size that’s a straightforward no.

After the deposit, tie payments to milestones rather than to calendar dates, so each one is triggered by something you can see:

• Rough in complete and approved
• Drywall hung and finished
• Cabinets set
• Substantial completion

Keep the last payment large enough that finishing matters. Holding 10 to 15 percent until the final inspection passes and the punch list is genuinely done is the single most effective thing you can do to avoid the slow fade at the end of a project, where the crew is 95 percent finished and increasingly hard to reach.

Pay by check or card, never in cash. A cash discount is a request to leave no record of the transaction, which is exactly the record you’d need if anything goes wrong.

---

The Red Flags Worth Walking Away From

Any one of these is a reason to stop:

• No PA registration number on the estimate or the contract. The law requires it there.
• They ask you to pull the permit. That shifts responsibility for the work and its inspections onto you, and it usually means a registration, insurance or licensing problem on their side.
• A deposit over one third. Or any pressure to pay more up front than the work justifies.
• Cash only, or a discount for cash. No record, no recourse.
• Door to door solicitation with a price that expires today. Legitimate remodelers are booked out, not out driving neighborhoods looking for signatures this afternoon.
• No written contract, or a one page contract with no dates and no scope. The law requires the written version for anything over $500.
• They won’t give you the insurance agent’s contact information.
• They badmouth every other contractor in the area. People confident in their own work don’t need to.

---

Questions Worth Asking at the Estimate Meeting

The estimate meeting is the only chance you get to watch someone answer questions before you’re paying them. Six that reveal the most:

• Who will be on my property every day, your crew or subcontractors? Neither answer is wrong. A vague answer is.
• Who is my single point of contact, and how do I reach them? If it’s the owner and the owner is running five jobs, ask what happens on the days they’re on the other four.
• What happens when demolition turns up something nobody priced? Listen for a process, not a reassurance.
• Which items have lead times over four weeks, and when do they get ordered? This is the question that predicts whether your project finishes near its estimate.
• Who pulls the permit and schedules inspections? The answer should be them, without hesitation.
• What does your warranty cover, for how long, and is it in writing?

You’re not testing their knowledge. You’re testing whether they’ve thought about your project as a project rather than as a sale.

---

When to Hire a Remodeling Contractor, and When to Walk

Once you have your bids in hand, the call is usually simpler than it feels:

• If a contractor isn’t registered, stop there. Nothing else about them matters enough to outweigh it.
• If two bids are close and one is far lower, ask the low bidder what’s different about their scope before you assume you found a deal. Usually they’ll tell you.
• If a contractor won’t put a start and completion date in writing, treat that as a preview of how the schedule will be managed, and ask what actually drives their timeline before you decide.
• If everything checks out and you still feel uneasy after the estimate meeting, that’s data. You’ll be sharing your house with these people for weeks.
• If two contractors are equally qualified, go with the one who answered your hardest question most directly. That’s how they’ll answer the hard question that comes up in week four.

Around Wilkes-Barre and Luzerne County, where a lot of homes predate the codes they’re now measured against, the odds of a surprise behind a wall are higher than average. That raises the value of everything above, because the contractor you pick isn’t just pricing the work you can see. They’re the one who’ll be standing in your kitchen when the wall comes open.

If you’re at that stage and want an estimate with a written scope, fixed pricing, and a real start and finish date to compare against your other bids, call 570 Remodeling at (570) 938-4541 or request a free quote. Bring the checklist above and hold us to it.

---

FAQ

Do contractors need a license in Pennsylvania?

Not a statewide general contractor license, because Pennsylvania doesn’t issue one. What the state requires is registration with the Office of Attorney General under the Home Improvement Consumer Protection Act for anyone doing $5,000 or more of home improvement work in a calendar year. Specific trades like electricians and plumbers can still face separate local licensing.

How do I check if a contractor is registered in Pennsylvania?

Search the Attorney General’s Home Improvement Contractor Search at hicsearch.attorneygeneral.gov by registration number, business name, owner name or county. You can also call the Bureau of Consumer Protection at 1-888-520-6680. Their PA registration number should already be printed on the estimate they gave you, because the law requires it there.

How much of a deposit should I give a remodeling contractor?

No more than one third of the contract price, plus the cost of any materials that have to be special ordered. That’s the standard Pennsylvania’s law works from. A request for half or more up front is a reason to ask hard questions or walk.

How many quotes should I get for a remodel?

Three is the useful number, as long as all three are pricing an identical written scope. Two makes it hard to spot an outlier and more than four tends to produce noise rather than clarity. Comparability matters far more than quantity.

Can I cancel a contract after I’ve signed it?

You have three business days to cancel a home improvement contract in Pennsylvania, and the contractor is required to give you that notice in writing. If they never did, the contract may be voidable even after those three days have passed.

Should I pay a contractor in cash?

No. Pay by check or card so there’s a record of every payment tied to a milestone. A discount offered for cash is a request to make the transaction invisible, which removes the paper trail you’d need in a dispute.

What should I ask a contractor’s references?

Ask what went wrong and how it was handled, whether the final price matched the contract, whether changes were documented in writing, and whether they’d hire the contractor again for something larger. Ask for references from two or three years ago, since recent jobs can’t tell you how the work held up.

Is a registration number the same as a license number?

No. A Pennsylvania registration number confirms a contractor filed with the state and carries the minimum required insurance. It doesn’t certify skill, training or quality of workmanship, which is why references and a detailed written contract still do the heavy lifting.